Showing posts with label Cleft Palate. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Cleft Palate. Show all posts

Wednesday, September 20, 2023

The Social Changes of Today - Increased Identitarian Thinking - and the Clefted


     Non discrimination once betokened a tolerant, egalitarian outlook. So long as everyone abided by general civic standards, good citizenship meant, Don’t stick your nose in other people’s business. Let them pursue happiness. It is the standard of a liberal society which leaves you alone and lets you be.
     A recent article on how to be an anti racist imposed requirements which go beyond the standard of a liberal society. A selective, some-animals-are-more-equal-than-others standard prescribes caution about those highly ranked in the politics-of-identity hierarchy. Minorities, women, and LGBTQ people are treated with caution. Everyone else, you can probably diss. This is not to the advantage of the clefted.

     What has happened is that today, groups are more likely to think of themselves as a collective. An in-group which has its own group interests. The specific example: Until recently, dwelling in an apartment building was relatively anonymous. Populated by individuals from all walks of life. In this and the previous building I lived in, there’s been something new - the sense that “You’re not part of our in-group. Nobody likes misfits. We have the right to say, you’re not wanted here.”
     The general increase in prejudices that the civil rights laws of the mid-sixties had been thought to discredit - increasing hostility toward minorities, different gender orientations, etc. - is also adverse to disabled people.

     The liberty intended in The Declaration and the Bill of Rights was founded on a non-identitarian outlook. “We the People” is the classic statement that identity should not matter in a free society. The classic opposite was Marx’s announcement that the proletariat was inherently good and the bourgeoisie - their exploiter - was inherently bad. Columnist Andrew Sullivan suggests that we have a “Neo-Marxism” in which women, minorities, and LGBTQ people are good, and the rest are guilty of “privilege.” Born good and born bad, in effect.
     There was already a tendency against those who were born “different”  - tragic Oedipus, whose name means “swollen foot,” and the scriptural “Master, who sinned, this man or his parents, that he was born thus?” Again, this undoing of the gains of the civil rights laws of the mid-sixties does those who have a cleft little good.
     Identitarianism implicitly elevates some identities at the expense of others, at the cost of the ideal of human equality.

Monday, November 14, 2022

The religious notion of Original Sin and the cleft palate community.



The doctrine of Original Sin appears in two Abrahamic religions of the First World, the religion of the Israelite tribes, which by the first century of the Common Era had been named Judaism; and the religion based on a first century practitioner of that religion, Jesus of Nazareth, Christianity.

A common expression in these religions is, Through Adam (the symbolic first man) did all men sin; every person is born inheriting this sin. We, until Christian salvation, are all sinners.
Disabled people, particularly so. Consider the passage from the Gospel of John in the Christian scriptures, where Jesus is confronted with a man born disabled. “Master,” the people ask, “who sinned, this man, or his parents, that he was born thus?”
Particularly for clefted people, by and large physically able except for the social stigma (implied in the catchphrase “I don’t care if it h-words the Governor), Original Sin can produce a kind of knee-jerk discrimination at the very outset of our social interactions.

In our medical care, the dogma of Original Sin can make a diagnosis of illness an accusation of illness.
A personal example. In middle age, the back pressure from prostate enlargement produced blood changes. I was sent to a specialist who said these changes were a multiple myeloma indicator. Although I asked if the prostate condition could be the cause, he performed a bone marrow biopsy and had me undergo a skeletal X-ray. Although a second opinion said the biopsy did not indicate cancer, and the X-ray didn’t find anything, he wanted to start chemotherapy. I insisted on waiting until we actually knew something.

Not only is the doctrine of Original Sin a harmful premise which frequently produces unfounded accusations, there are counter arguments in the very religions from which it arose; and in secular society it violates it violates a founding liberal principle: the presumption of innocence. I was attending the christening of a grandchild when, to my astonishment, the priest read a passage from the Torah/Tanakh which contradicted a dogma of his faith. Ezekiel 18 is an extended argument against Original Sin: “Yet say ye, Why? doth not the son bear the iniquity of the father? … The son shall not bear the iniquity of the father, …But if the wicked will turn from all his sins that he hath committed, and keep all my statutes, and do that which is lawful and right, he shall surely live, he shall not die.” (Emphasis added)

Likewise, for Christians, in the parable of the prodigal son, Jesus is saying that he does not hold with the dogma of Original Sin either. Key passage: “He came to himself.” As in the passage from hundreds of years earlier, the key word is “turn.”

Original Sin makes a society which is inclined to be prejudicial toward the clefted even more so. But there are countervailing arguments in the very religions originating it, and our universal justice assures us that the presumption of innocence is our unalienable right.

/******/


A reciprocity principle: If a remark or an action or an attitude would be seen as discriminatory if directed toward a minority, it is discriminatory for us. We have exactly the same civil rights, even if the justice system does not act as if we do.

Wednesday, June 15, 2022

A day in the life

 Experiences I’ve had that maybe you have too.

One gets hired for a position, and does well in it. Sooner or later there’s an office shuffle, and there’s a new supervisor. They’re cleft phobic, and make life hell - but nobody seems to notice.(1)

A simple ride on the city bus system goes south. I once took a seat near the front of the bus opposite a scrawny woman in a wheelchair. As the bus got rolling, she got out one of those little dollar bottles of gin and commenced trying to open it. She asked passengers to help. When she asked me, I smiled and demurred. No drinking on Metro Transit. “You are weak!” she said, and started repeating it in a loud voice, verbal abuse that surely the driver could hear. (I wondered if I should suggest to the driver that the civil rights of a disabled person were being violated on government property - but decided not to bother.)

You go to a party, and someone asks you what seems to be a friendly question. This turns into derogatory rhetorical questions, and instead of a happy occasion, you find yourself on the hot seat - people backing away. Presumably this doesn’t happen with minorities, women, or LGBTQ people - people in a protected class.

A stranger remarks, “I knew a guy like you” - another person who was “different” - clefted.

Even government offices aren’t safe. I was meeting with an employment counselor when their co-worker nearby loudly joked about a moustached employee’s “hair lip.” A State Driver’s License photographer said, “Cheese, whiskey, harelip.”

You are admitted to the graduate school of a public university, and as soon as they see you there’s a chill. I experienced this in both a Midwestern and a West Coast university. (A city university just starting its graduate program acted the way higher education ought to act, and I had no difficulty getting a graduate degree there.) Are universities in the performative era afraid that having certain kinds of disabled people bearing their credentials out into the world would harm their reputations? 

These things add up. They constitute stigma, and result in what Sociologist Erving Goffman called “reduced life chances.”

/******/

(1) When I was working for the City Comptroller’s Office, I once came back from a week’s vacation to find co-workers acting a little strange. Finally, someone took me aside and said one of our people from across the hall had gone to my supervisor’s supervisor (a CPA, one of the ethical occupations) and complained about the way I was constantly being dressed down in front of everybody. The CPA said, “That’s a serious charge. It would need to be documented,” - and she pulled out a list of times and what was said.


Monday, January 10, 2022

What is the policy toward cleft palate people where you live? Who created it? Who administers it?

This morning, it occurs that this fundamental question hasn’t been answered in my city, my county, my state, my country. Are the clefted an interest group, a needs group, an identity, a resource, a “problem?”

A possible starting point. In my Pacific Northwest city, if you go to a dentist needing an upper plate, they direct you to the Faculty Prosthodontics center of the medical division of the state university. Parents having a newborn with a cleft are directed to Children’s Hospital in this city.
By contrast, the Disability Rights Washington website, according to a Google Site Search, does not mention “cleft,” “palate,” “hare,” “lip,” or any combination of these terms.
The United States has public programs structured for needs groups, such as the elderly; and members of an identity having perceived needs, such as minorities, women, and LGBTQ people. The first is general, public, and neutral, such as the statement beginning the Constitution: “We the People.” Social Security and Medicare do not suggest that elderly people are more worthy than the young; only that their reduced earning capacity and increased medical expenses need the general solution government can provide.
The second solution, in terms of identity, is less desirable from the standpoint of democracy.

The first problem for clefted people is that there is little or no unified social or governmental response to our civil rights needs, or our economic needs. By contrast, the civil rights needs of minorities are addressed, for example, by the Civil Rights Act of the sixties, by directed court attention, and by minority assistance programs. Do Faculty Prosthodontics, Children’s Hospital, and Disability Rights Washington coordinate? It is left up to the clefted person to figure out where to go.
Cleft people’s civil rights problems are suggested by the public attitude of the familiar “I don’t care if it h-words the Governor”(1) slur. I asked an attorney who specializes in “disability discrimination cases in higher education” if she knew of any cases where the courts had addressed the pervasive public discrimination against clefted people. Her emailed response evaded the issue. A 2013 post in this blog cited an ADA: “There's case law out there regarding people commenting and gesturing against race and religion. But ... there's nothing out there regarding disabilities.”

/******/

Initial thoughts concerning what an initial program for the one in seven hundred who have a cleft might address:

1. Provide a clearinghouse where people having a cleft can contact each other
2. Provide someone clefted people can contact to evaluate incidents which may be discriminatory
3. Provide a resource for determining if effective action can be taken to counteract discrimination
4. Resources who can intercede for targeted disabled people. Could pro bono legal assistance be leveraged when civil rights may be being infringed?
5. Counteract the pressure clefted people are under to keep silent
6. Develop a cleft discourse (example: Should pervasive negative reaction to clefted people, where found, be described as “cleftphobic?”)
7. Promote public awareness that cleft people have exactly the same rights as minorities, women, and LGBTQ people
8. Determine what legal precedent exists where cleft civil rights may have been violated



/******/

(1) In this slur, the American public doesn’t imply that the worst fate for the Governor would be to wake up as a person of color, but to wake disfigured by a cleft.
In the politics of identity, victim status is what counts. The public seems to regard disfigurement as a greater disadvantage than race.