A corollary of “I don’t care if it [h-words] the Governor”: I take it that the fact that the h-word was chosen over the n-word means that the general public considers the pervasively stigmatized birth defect to be a worse identity than the nation’s most targeted race. Other factors:
- There are virtually no governmental or social institutions for adult people having a cleft.
- Absence of legal prior art: “There's case law out there regarding people commenting and gesturing against race and religion. But ... there's nothing out there regarding disabilities.”
- Either actually, or publicly regarded as, not in a protected class. Few or no cases at law concerning our civil rights.
- Roughly one in seven hundred. Not enough to have any influence on politics.
- Related absence of community. If I am typical, many clefted people don’t know anyone like them. And the mainstream people they know may be less than reliable friends.
- Little or no social or legal cost to slighting us, abusing us, or having an attitude of disrespect toward us.
- Some, perhaps most, of us have families that simply will not talk about cleft palate. That, in itself, is probably a civil rights violation. Such families have a significant tendency to turn a blind eye when bigoted people get on our case. Families should be part of the solution. Often they are instead part of the problem.
- People having a cleft are often blamed and scapegoated. Sometimes they even considered guilty for the way they were born.
- If a person of color targets a clefted person of a different race, the person being targeted may be accused of racism if they defend themselves.
- An example of some of these things: I was in a state office having my drivers license picture taken. The state employee said, “Cheese, whiskey, [h-word].” I know a person of color my age. If the state representative had done the same thing, substituting the [n-word], he could have gone home and talked to a bunch of people who were in the same boat. The situation of us clefted ones is utterly different - anyone we might mention it to would probably get a pained expression, as if we’d violated a social rule.
Summary: In an issue between a person having a cleft palate and anyone, the disabled person is almost certainly at a major disadvantage.
No comments:
Post a Comment